PEANUT BUTTER CO. - CAPE MAY & SMITHVILLE NJ
The Cape May Peanut Butter Company planted roots and the smells of fresh ground nut butters allowed us to quickly plant our roots as customers came to get their peanut butter fix. Not only do we carry offer gourmet spreads and peanut butter themed goods of all kinds, but we also grind fresh nut butters right in store and offer a huge variety of fresh baked goodies. Our delightful shop is THE mecca for peanut butter loves — and a bonus is that we’re just a steps from the beach.
We have nine nut butter flavors to choose from, including Honey Roast, Butter Scotch, Capu Cino, Choc Choc, Natural, Almond, Sunflower, Cashew, and Organic. Trust us when we say we have a flavor for all tastes and styles!
In addition to these sought after nut butters, we have over 40 flavors of jam including carrot cake, habanero, oatmeal stout, India pale ale and of course, grape and strawberry. Because what would our insanely great peanut butter be without a little jam?
And when the warm aromas of fresh baked brownies and cookies create the urge to indulge, you can heed the call by enjoying your treats in our beautiful courtyard seating area or bag them up and take them to the beach with you. Pets are also welcome in our open air courtyard, and they’ll love our treats just as much as you — we have plenty of peanut butter treats for dogs, too!
Enjoy your food in our courtyard seating or take them to the beach with you for the day. Not only is our courtyard pet-friendly, but our offerings are as well! Our peanut butter dog treats have been rated as paws-a-tively delicious by our canine cohorts, and we proudly donate to Animal Outreach of Cape May County.

NUT BUTTERS & GOURMET PEANUT BUTTER SPECIALTIES
 |
-
 |
 |
Zippy's Almond & Apricot Bar
16 / Cape Island Foods
In honor of our furry friend that visits the shop at Cape May Peanut Butter Co.,...
$1.99
|
-
 |
 |
Zippy's Nut & Cranberry Bar
16 / Cape Island Foods
In honor of our furry friend that visits the shop at Cape May Peanut Butter Co.,...
$1.99
|
-
 |
 |
Spreader
23 / Cape Island Foods
Cape May Peanut Butter Co Spreader is perfect make all of your PB&J sandwich...
$2.95
|
-
-
-
 |
 |
Natural Peanut Butter
1 / Cape Island Foods
Our Natural Peanut Butter is made with dry roasted peanuts and salt. Great for b...
$4.99
|
-
-
 |
 |
Banana Jam
3 / Mrs. Miller's
Mrs. Miller's Banana Jam. A Nice Addition To Breads & Muffins, Use To Top Ic...
$5.95
|
-
-
 |
 |
F.R.O.G. Jam
3 / Mrs. Miller's
This flavor may have a unique name, but its combination of familiar flavors yiel...
$5.95
|
-
 |
 |
Mango Jam
3 / Mrs. Miller's
Made with sweet tropical mango fruit, Mrs. Miller's Homemade Mango Jam is a tast...
$5.95
|
-
 |
 |
Peanut Clusters
6 / Cape Island Foods
6 delicious ounces of Peanut Butter and Chocolate Covered Peanut Clusters.
$5.95
|
-
 |
 |
Butterscotch Peanut Butter
1 / Cape Island Foods
Our Butterscotch Peanut Butter is made with roasted peanuts and butterscotch pie...
$5.99
|
-
 |
 |
Capu Cino Peanut Butter
1 / Cape Island Foods
Serving Size- 2 Tablespoons. Ingredients: Roasted Peanuts, Butterscotch Drops, C...
$5.99
|
-
 |
 |
Choc Choc Peanut Butter
1 / Cape Island Foods
Our Chocolate Peanut Butter is made with roasted peanuts and chocolate chips. Sp...
$5.99
|
-
 |
 |
Honey Roast Peanut Butter
1 / Cape Island Foods
This is our #1 selling Nut Butter! Eat it by the spoonful or put with anything y...
$5.99
|
-
 |
 |
Sunflower Seed Butter
1 / Cape Island Foods
Natural Sunflower - 8 oz. Ingredients: Roasted Sunflower Kernels, Sunflower Oil ...
$5.99
|
-
-
 |
 |
Spicy Tikka Masala Soup Mix
23 / Cape Island Foods
A vibrant Indian blend of Rice, Vegetables, & Spices.
All you need to do is...
$6.95
|
-
-
 |
 |
Spicy Thai Shrimp Soup Mix
23 / Cape Island Foods
Exotic Far- East flavors with a little bite.
All you need to do is add stock &a...
$6.95
|
-
 |
 |
Southern Peanut Soup Mix
23 / Cape Island Foods
A hearty blend of peanut flour, vegetables and spices. Just add stock, cream and...
$6.95
|
-
 |
 |
Curry Peanut Soup Mix
23 / Cape Island Foods
A hearty blend of peanut flour, vegetables and spices. Just add stock and heat!
$6.95
|
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
 |
 |
Organic Peanut Butter
1 / Cape Island Foods
Serving Size- 2 Tablespoons. Ingredients: Dry Roasted Organic Peanuts
$6.99
|
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
 |
 |
Coconut Peanut Clusters
6 / Cape Island Foods
6 delicious ounces of Coconut, Peanut Butter and Chocolate Covered Peanut Cluste...
$7.95
|
-
-
-
 |
 |
Old Bay Peanuts
2 / Virginia Diner Peanuts
Virginia Diner Old Bay Peanuts. Available in 10oz
$8.95
|
-
 |
 |
Sweet Onion Peanuts
2 / Virginia Diner Peanuts
Virginia Diner Sweet Onion Peanuts. Available in 10oz
$8.95
|
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
 |
 |
Almond Nut Butter
1 / Cape Island Foods
Our Almond Butter is made with nothing other than roasted almonds! Serving Size-...
$8.99
|
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
 |
 |
Blister Fried Peanuts
2 / Bertie County Peanuts
Bertie County Blister Fried Peanuts are available in 10 oz and 30 oz sizes.
$9.95
|
-
-
 |
 |
Salt & Pepper Peanuts
2 / Bertie County Peanuts
Sea Salt and Black Pepper Bertie County Peanuts. Available in 10 oz. and 30 oz.
$9.95
|
-
-
-
-
-
-
 |
 |
Raspberry Pecan Preserves
3 / San Saba River Pecan Co.
Pairing pecans with raspberries makes for a delightful addition to your breakfas...
$9.95
|
-
-
-
 |
 |
Peanut Butter Cookie Dough
6 / Cape Island Foods
It's Here.... Peanut Butter Cookie Dough! Eat It, Don't Bake It! This products...
$9.99
|
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
 |
 |
Heart Of Non Pareils
6 / Cape Island Foods
Perfect Gift For The Candy Lover In Your Life. Just In Time For Valentine's Day ...
$12.95
|
-
-
-
-
 |
 |
Peanut Butter & Jelly Sock
7 / Cape Island Foods
Be the life of the party... or maybe just lunch with these really cool PB & ...
$12.95
|
-
-
 |
 |
Cashew Nut Butter
1 / Cape Island Foods
Natural Cashew - 8 oz. Serving Size- 2 Tablespoons. Ingredients: Roasted Cashews...
$12.99
|
-
-
-
 |
 |
Cocoa Cashews
6 / Cape Island Foods
Seriously, you'll love these delicious Cocoa Dusted Chocolate Cashews so much yo...
$13.95
|
-
-
-
 |
 |
Creamed Cinnamon Honey
9 / Busy Bees Honey
Creamed Cinnamon Honey Spread - Busy Bees NJ. 3/4 pound (12 ounces)
$15.50
|
-
-
-
-
-
-
 |
 |
Spread The Love Tshirt
7 / Cape Island Foods
Help spread the love with our Spread the Love T-Shirt from Cape May Peanut Butte...
$24.95
|
-
-
-
 |
 |
Peanut Butter Party Box
31 / Cape Island Foods
Contains 5 Ea - of our finest flavors in a 3 Oz Size. Natural, Butterscotc...
$29.99
|
-
 |
 |
PB Gift Set 6
31 / Cape Island Foods
With each gift basket you will receive a Natural Peanut Butter, an additional pe...
$29.99
|
-
 |
 |
Small Batch Four Pack
1 / Cape Island Foods
Our Annual SMALL BATCH 4 Pack offering. Featuring 4 of our popular SMALL B...
$29.99
|
-
 |
 |
PB Gift Set 3
31 / Cape Island Foods
Gift Set Includes:
1 - 8oz Natural Peanut Butter
1 - 8oz Butterscotch Peanut B...
$39.95
|
-
-
 |
 |
PB Gift Set 4-The Sampler
31 / Cape Island Foods
Each Gift Set Includes:
1 - Candied Curry Hauz Peanuts
1 - 8oz Honey Roa...
$79.95
|
|
 |
|