OLIVE OIL COMPANY - CAPE MAY NJ

The Cape May Olive Oil Company welcomes you to your happy place! Our lovely store, located just steps from the beaches of America’s Oldest Seaside Resort, is stocked full of dozens of different olive oils, balsamic vinegars, spreads, pasta, and more. Our insanely popular jams, mustards and dips have been a staple of the Cape May culinary scene since the moment we first stocked our shelves and we never looked back!

We welcome you to browse our online store, where you can order a variety of custom olive oil blends, infused salts & sugars, and anything else your heart desires. When you combine olive oil and the warm sunny beach days in Cape May, NJ, you’re sure to think of plenty of friends and family who’d love a little of both.

Where ever our travels may take us, we’re constantly on the hunt for the next best olive oil, so be sure to stop back often. Our curiosity to travel is only surpassed by our desire to offer the finest products!

GOURMET OLIVE OILS & SPECIALTY PRODUCTS

Pour Spout 23 / Webstaurant $3.74 Smargiassi Seasoned Crostini 16 / Cape Island Foods $4.00 Unique Original Splits Pretzels 16 /  $4.00 Unique Extra Dark Splits Pretzels 16 /  $4.00 Unique Extra Salt Splits Pretzels 16 /  $4.00 Uncle Harolds Tortilla Chips 16 / Uncle Harolds $5.00 Terrapin Braided Pretzels 16 / Terrapin Ridge $5.00 Spreader 23 / Olive Wood $6.95 Mulligatawny Soup Mix 23 / Cape Island Foods $6.95 Roasted Garlic Crackers 16 / La Panzanella $6.95 Original Crackers 16 / La Panzanella $6.95 Rosemary Crackers 16 / La Panzanella $6.95 Toasted Sesame Crackers 16 / La Panzanella This product contains sesame, an FDA listed food allergen. $6.95 Boska Small Cutting Board 23 / Boska $6.99 Bottle Cork 23 / Olive Wood $7.95 Olive Picker 23 / Olive Wood $7.95 Olive Oil Granola - Original 16 / Cape Island Foods $7.95 Parsley Mint Dog Treat 5 / Cape Island Foods $8.99 Bacon Aioli Squeeze Bottle 42 / Terrapin Ridge Smokey bacon and tart Dijon mustard will delight the taste buds in this velvety ... $9.95 Everything Aioli Squeeze Bottle 42 / Terrapin Ridge We call this everything aioli because you are going to want it on EVERYTHING. It... $9.95 Spicy Chipotle Squeeze Bottle 42 / Terrapin Ridge A well-blended balance of chipotle peppers, spices, cider vinegar and the zip of... $9.95 Sriracha Horseradish Aioli Squeeze Bottle 42 / Terrapin Ridge Sriracha and Horseradish give this sauce a one-two punch.  Enliven gourmet ... $9.95 Spatula 23 / Olive Wood $9.95 Spoon 23 / Olive Wood $9.95 Creamy Garlic Mustard 20 / Terrapin Ridge This incredible combination of garlic, Neufachtel cheese and creamy mustard will... $9.95 Smokey Onion Mustard 20 / Terrapin Ridge A burger and brat lover's dream. Natural smoke flavor & crisp onions create ... $9.95 Dill Pickle Mustard 20 / Terrapin Ridge Mouthwatering dill pickles and smooth Dijon... it's the mustard you've been wait... $9.95 Chipotle Bean Dip 42 / Elki Down-home Southwest flavor. Smoky heat and a hint of sweet make this a fun choic... $9.99 Cucumber Wasabi Dip 42 / Elki Fresh, smooth, and vibrant. An innovative blend of cool cucumbers with the heat ... $9.99 Smoky Bacon Cheddar Dip 42 / Elki Two bold flavors make one American favorite. Woody, smoked bacon and sharp chedd... $9.99 Sundried Tomato & Parm Spread 42 / Elki A Mediterranean inspired blend of sun dried tomatoes, parmesan cheese, balsamic ... $9.99 Habanero Ancho Hot Sauce 13 / Born To Hula $9.99 Habanero Guajillo Hot Sauce 13 / Born To Hula $9.99 Ghost Of Ancho Hot Sauce 13 / Born To Hula $9.99 Reaper Of Sorrow Hot Sauce 13 / Born To Hula $9.99 Smokehaus Blues Hot Sauce 13 / Born To Hula $9.99 Cayenne Hot Sauce 13 / Born To Hula $9.99 Harvest Hot Sauce 13 / Born To Hula $9.99 Amber Beer Mustard 20 / Sutter Buttes $9.99 Chardonnay Mustard 20 / Sutter Buttes $9.99 Jalapeno Whiskey Mustard 20 / Sutter Buttes $9.99 Artichoke Spinach Dip 42 / Rothschild The subtle flavor of artichokes, aged Romano cheese, baby spinach and garlic is ... $10.00 Onion Blossom Horseradish Dip 42 / Rothschild This flavorful dip features horseradish, savory herbs, and spices blended into a... $10.00 Smoky Fig & Roasted Garlic Spread 42 / Rothschild Chunks of sweet figs, bold roasted garlic and a subtle onion flavor are blended ... $10.00 Hatch Chili Bacon Ranch Dip 42 / Terrapin Ridge Roasted red bell pepper puree, Hatch Chile peppers and bacon are added to creamy... $10.00 Natural 3 Olive Mix Pitted 24 / LOSADA 168gr $10.00 Natural Alorena Olives Pitted 24 / LOSADA 168gr $10.00 Conventional Gordal Olives Pitted 24 / LOSADA 168gr $10.00 Natural Carmona Olives Mix 24 / LOSADA 198gr $10.00 Anna Mae's Smoky Mustard 20 / Rothschild $10.00 Blue Cheese Dijon Mustard 20 / Rothschild $10.00 Raspberry Honey Mustard Dip Glaze 20 / Rothschild $10.00 Oil & Spice Gift Set 31 / Cape Island Foods Our Own Cape May Blend With Smargiassi Spice $10.99 Burgandy Mustard 20 / Edmond Fallot $11.95 Tarragon Mustard 20 / Edmond Fallot $11.95 Black Currant Mustard 20 / Edmond Fallot $11.95 Green Peppercorn Mustard 20 / Edmond Fallot $11.95 Walnut Mustard 20 / Edmond Fallot $11.95 Honey Balsamic Mustard 20 / Edmond Fallot $11.95 Cajun Jalapeno Olives 24 / Sutter Buttes $11.99 Artichoke Lemon Pesto 42 / Elki Sunny and fresh, a delightful combination of flavors. A pesto spread with endles... $11.99 Asparagus & Italian Cheese Pesto 42 / Elki A nut-free pesto with plenty of bright, sunny flavors.Succulent, ripe asparagus ... $11.99 Basil Pesto 42 / Elki A classic Mediterranean treat. Uniquely nut-free and full of flavor.Fresh, aroma... $11.99 Green Olive Tapenade 42 / Elki Mediterranean vegetables, imported olives, and spices. Hearty texture and robust... $11.99 Farmhouse Tapenade 42 / Sutter Buttes $11.99 Sundried Tomato & Olive Tapenade 42 / Sutter Buttes $11.99 Artichoke & Tomato Bruschetta 42 / Elki Tender, juicy artichokes, complemented by sun-ripened tomatoes and sweet red and... $11.99 Asparagus Asiago Bruschetta 42 / Elki Mouthwatering sun-ripened asparagus. A unique combination of sweet and salty.Asi... $11.99 Sweet Red Pepper Bruschetta 42 / Elki A sweet and piquant blend with a little kick, including sun ripened sweet red pe... $11.99 Balsamic Fig Mostarda Spread 42 / Wozz Balsamic Fig Mostarda Spread -  Our signature cheese pairing spread&nb... $12.00 Jamacian Jerk Pineapple Chutney 42 / Wozz Jamaican Jerk Pineapple Gourmet Chutney- Fresh grilled pineapple, Jamaican Jerk ... $12.00 Morrocan Tomato Onion Relish 42 / Wozz Moroccan Tomato Onion Relish - Slow cooked tomatoes in a blend of aromatic ... $12.00 Spicy Summer Mango Chutney 42 / Wozz Spicy Summer Mango Gourmet Chutney - Fresh mango infused with slow cooked a... $12.00 Triple Ale Onion Spread 42 / Wozz Triple Ale Onion Savory Spread - a sweet savory onion spread made with roas... $12.00 Roast Pineapple Habanero Sauce 42 / Terrapin Ridge Roasted Pineapple & Habanero is a hit among everyone from fanatical foodies ... $12.95 Danger Close Hot Sauce 13 / The General's $12.99 Dead Red Hot Sauce 13 / The General's $12.99 Shock and Awe Hot Sauce 13 / The General's $12.99 Grunt Green Hot Sauce 13 / The General's $12.99 Maple Mayhem Hot Sauce 13 / The General's $12.99 Porcini Truffle Tapenade 42 / Sutter Buttes $13.00 Uncured Salami Chub - Finocchiona 13 / Coro $14.95 Uncured Salami Chub - Mole 13 / Coro $14.95 Paddle 23 / Olive Wood $14.95 Uncured Salami Chub - Classic 13 / Coro $14.95 Uncured Salami Chub - Lemongrass 13 / Coco $14.95 Uncured Salami Chub - Agrumi 13 / Coro $14.95 Chardonnay Wine Vinegar 10 / O-Med 250ml $15.00 Cabernet Sauvignon Wine Vinegar 10 / O-Med 250ml $15.00 Moscatel Wine Vinegar 10 / O-Med 250ml $15.00 Sherry Wine Vinegar 10 / O-Med 250ml $15.00 Rose Wine Vinegar 10 / O-Med 250ml $15.00 Apple Cider Vinegar 10 / O-Med 250ml $15.00 Chianti Wine Vinegar 10 / Bal Vendor $15.00 Spoon Shaped Spoon Rest 23 / Naturally Med $15.00 Spiced Beet Vinegar 10 / Wozz $17.99 Blueberry Maple Vinegar 10 / Wozz $17.99 Cranberry Saffron Vinegar 10 / Wozz $17.99 Pear Ginger Vinegar 10 / Wozz $17.99 Strawberry Rhubarb Vinegar 10 / Wozz $17.99 Fork / Spoon 23 / Olive Wood $19.95 Cherry Almond Seasonal Tart Kit 23 / Cape Island Foods $19.95 Anettes Belgian Chocolate Brandy Sauce 10 / Anettes $19.95 Anettes Butterscotch Scotch Sauce 10 / Anettes $19.99 Anettes Chocolate Port Wine Sauce 10 / Anettes $19.99 Anettes Dark Chocolate Espresso Liquer Sauce 10 / Anettes $19.99 Black Cherry Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Blueberry Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Blood Orange Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Black Walnut Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Dark Chocolate Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Cranberry Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 White Cranberry Pear Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 White Lemon Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Caramel Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Cucumber Melon Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Chocolate Raspberry Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Chocolate Jalepeno Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Fig Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Mango Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Pear Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Pomegranate Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 White Peach Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Chile Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Espresso Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Raspberry Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Strawberry Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Traditional Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 White Traditional Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 White Coconut Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 White Pineapple Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Pumpkin Pie Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Smoked Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Red Apple Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Bacon EVOO 18 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 White Honey Ginger Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Basil EVOO 18 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Lavender Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Blood Orange EVOO 18 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Butter EVOO 18 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Chipotle EVOO 18 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Citrus Habanero EVOO 18 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Garlic EVOO 18 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Jalapeno EVOO 18 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Meyer Lemon EVOO 18 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Oregano EVOO 18 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Parmesan Garlic EVOO 18 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Persian Lime EVOO 18 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Roasted Onion EVOO 18 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Rosemary EVOO 18 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Tuscan Herb EVOO 18 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Arbequina EVOO 18 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Hojiblanca EVOO 18 /  $20.00 Koroneiki EVOO 18 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Vanilla Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Blackberry Ginger Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Truffle Balsamic 11 / Cape Island Foods $20.00 Serving Board W/Handle 13" X 5" 23 / Naturally Med $20.00 OO Gift Set 8 Spice Cellar Trio 31 / Cape Island Foods TRUFFLE SET - Includes:  WHite Truffle Oil, Black Truffle Oil, Truffle Salt... $21.95 OO Gift Set 8 Spice Cellar Trio 31 / Cape Island Foods $21.95 Bottle Holder 23 / Olive Wood $24.95 Rolling Pin 23 / Olive Wood $24.95 Cruet 23 / Bella Vita Gifts $24.99 Porcini EVOO 18 / Cape Island Foods $25.00 Cape May Blend EVOO 18 / Cape Island Foods $25.00 Nocellera de Belice EVOO 18 / Single Varietal Oil $25.00 Heart Shaped Board 8.25 23 / Naturally Med $25.00 Coaster Set 23 / Olive Wood $27.95 Ladle 23 / Olive Wood $29.95 Flav-Four Pack 31 / Cape Island Foods $29.99 Italian Herb Olive Oil 18 / Cape Island Foods $30.00 Rectangle Board 12" X 6" 23 / Naturally Med $30.00 Olive Dish & Olive Stabber 23 / Naturally Med $30.00 Black Truffle Olive Oil 18 / La Rustichella $32.00 Mortar / Pestle 23 / Olive Wood $34.95 Paddle with Border 23 / Olive Wood $34.95 O-Med Olive Pit Smoked Arbequina 18 / Philosophy Foods 250ml $34.95 Olive Oil & Vinegar Lover's Cookbook 23 / Cape Island Foods $35.00 White Truffle Olive Oil 18 / Cape Island Foods $35.00 Rincon de la Subbetica Organic Olive Oil 18 /  250ml $39.95 OO Gift Set 2 31 / Cape Island Foods Gift Set Includes: 1 - 375ml Cape May Blend Olive Oil 1 - Small Smargiassi Ble... $39.99 Piro EVOO 18 / Cape Island Foods $59.00 OO Gift Set 3 EASY HOSTESS 31 / Cape Island Foods USE CODE - GIFT5 - FOR $5.00 OFF - 1 WEEK ONLY - 5-11 APRIL '23 Gift Set Contai... $59.99 OO Gift Set 4 Cape May Lovers 31 / Cape Island Foods USE CODE - GIFT5 - FOR $5.00 OFF - 1 WEEK ONLY - 5-11 APRIL '23 This Gift Set C... $79.99 CS Gift Set 2 31 / Cape Island Foods Each Gift Set Includes: 1 - Lemoncello Almonds 1 - Roth Buttermilk Blue Cheese... $95.00 OO Gift Set 5 Hot & Spicy 31 / Cape Island Foods This Gift Set Contains 1 Each Of The Following: 375 ML Jalapeno Olive Oil Tann... $109.95 CS Gift Set 1 31 / Cape Island Foods Each Gift Set Includes: 1 - Sutter Buttes Parmesan Dipping Sauce 1 - Heritage ... $160.00